Nathan Head

as Father James

as Tyson Knight

as Tyson Knight

as Rick Loomis

as Seth Bethlehem

as Danny

as self (presenter)

as Andy (segment "Andy's Loss")

as Herman Webster Mudgett

as Dominic

as Mark

as Andy Deen (segment "Beer Cellar")

as Colin Green

as Officer Heinrich Berger

as Nathan (segment "Deathrealm")

as Karl Hendry

as Trinculo Moreau

as Professor Mastema

as Unknown Man

as Luke Railey

as Raymond Korkinsky

as The Archangel

as Jacob

as The alt. History Guy