Michael Rispoli

as Al

as Albert Anastasia

as Don Muchie Buchie

as Self

as Ray

as Stranger

as Tommy Lucchese

as Angelo

as Tommy

as Self

as Ray Higgins

as Coach Hannis

as Jim Hoffman

as Betty's Father

as Victor

as Rudy Pipilo

as Ray Ferguson

as Detective Guy Giordano

as Frank DiPascali

as Detective Dibronski

as Richie Sansome

as Don Warren

as Nick DeMaio

as Sal

as Dave Wheelan

as Tony

as Frank Griga

as Franco Puzzo

as Sean O'Grady

as Kevin Boyd

as Bel Jaffe

as Canton

as Sala

as Darien Makris

as Nick

as Tony V

as Vitale

as Jack Condo

as Big Joe

as Terrence

as Stu Harper

as John Johnson

as Mickey

as Jack (segment "Club Soda")

as Joey

as Jimmy Breslin

as Alo

as Alo (uncredited)

as Jack

as Max Cantrell

as Russ

as Babba

as Camper (voice)

as Boca

as Angelo Amonte

as Michael

as Spinner Dunn

as Frank Adair

as Swenson

as Ike Mannleigh

as Henry Taylor

as Buddy Visalo

as John Leone

as Jerry Mankowicz

as Henry Brazecki

as Joey T

as Jackie Aprile

as Det. Lt. Denny Reagan

as Grama

as Sam Bandusky

as Jimmy George

as Gator Harris

as Nick

as Manager of Motel

as Jack

as Joseph Boffano

as Ben DeLuca

as Joe Jr.

as Chris the Cop

as Frankie

as Victor Nable

as Richie

as Jerry

as Nicky Falconetti

as Trainer (uncredited)

as Pete Haynes

as Johnny DeMaio

as Michael