Ben Savage

as Nathaniel Kibby

as David Singer

as Stuart

as Self (archive footage)

as Cory Matthews

as Lincoln

as Scott

as Self

as Self - Presenter

as Carl

as Andy Burns

as Patrick

as Mark Ratner

as Ford Davis

as Young Gideon

as Jason Gideon

as Hugh Burnside

as Self

as Seth Cosella

as Kirby Morris

as Teddy Benevides

as Self - Host

as Self

as Cory Matthews

as Stuart

as Cory Matthews

as Richard Bickerstaff

as Roger

as Cory Matthews

as Coty Wyckoff

as Sam

as Andy

as Chris Bankston

as Eric Stevenson

as Matthew Lacey

as Curtis Hartsell