Michael Arden

as Milken Prince

as Elliot

as Paul's Drinking Friend

as Doug Wert

as Patrick

as Reverend Steve Stewart

as Joe Williams

as Derek Frost

as James Poole

as Finn

as Gabe

as Joseph Lasile

as Kevin

as Evan Kress

as Buddy

as Pinafore Actor

as Harold Prescott

as James Clark

as Neal Hannigan

as Whitley